what breed has the best network in your opinion?
what breed has the best network in your opinion?
Just sort of curious....I am always seeing different events being posted and seeing links to breeder organizations, testing sessions, and whatnot.
Without starting a back and forth....if a person were to want to buy a dog based solely on the amount of quality resources available for that specific breed, which one would it be? What breed really has a strong "network"?
Without starting a back and forth....if a person were to want to buy a dog based solely on the amount of quality resources available for that specific breed, which one would it be? What breed really has a strong "network"?
Re: what breed has the best network in your opinion?
Sorry I do not understand the question, nor the prohibition on back and forth. Whatever your asking it seem multiple opinions would be beneficial.
Re: what breed has the best network in your opinion?
Just don't want it to turn into an outright breed vs breed argument. Multiple opinions are great, but not what some threads turn into from what I have seen.Neil wrote:Sorry I do not understand the question, nor the prohibition on back and forth. Whatever your asking it seem multiple opinions would be beneficial.
Simply wondering what people's thoughts are as to what breed has the best network. Network meaning lots of things, but mostly, if someone needed resources for things like breed standard, training, trials, etc.
-
- Rank: Champion
- Posts: 301
- Joined: Thu Jan 01, 2015 11:39 pm
Re: what breed has the best network in your opinion?
GSP hands down. No other breed has had more success in more venues. Whether it be show, agility, hunt test, AKC Field Trials, American field Field Trials, NSTRA, UGA, Dock diving, NAvHDA, or the German Testing system.
However I wouldnt pick a breed based on this I would look for one that suits my liking. If I enjoy testing and the show ring I would probably look at a bench bred setter. If I wanted a dog to compete in a trial with I would loom at a Pointer, a Setter (AF or Cover Dog bred depending on trials), and a GSP. If your a hunter who wants to test I would probably look at a GSP, GWP or a PudelPointer, maybe even a vizsla.
Myself I live and hunt the prairies and got into trialing. I bought a GSP. My next dog will be a Pointer or Setter to play the AFTCA/AF trial game.
However I wouldnt pick a breed based on this I would look for one that suits my liking. If I enjoy testing and the show ring I would probably look at a bench bred setter. If I wanted a dog to compete in a trial with I would loom at a Pointer, a Setter (AF or Cover Dog bred depending on trials), and a GSP. If your a hunter who wants to test I would probably look at a GSP, GWP or a PudelPointer, maybe even a vizsla.
Myself I live and hunt the prairies and got into trialing. I bought a GSP. My next dog will be a Pointer or Setter to play the AFTCA/AF trial game.
Re: what breed has the best network in your opinion?
That is the way it appears if one browses this site, however that could simply be because GSP owners spend more time on forums lol! That is why I asked. I imagine that labs have quite the network as well?RyanDoolittle wrote:GSP hands down.
And neither would I, however in other realms, this type of thing can be the deciding factor to choose one over another.RyanDoolittle wrote:However I wouldnt pick a breed based on this I would look for one that suits my liking.
Re: what breed has the best network in your opinion?
There is not a nickels worth of difference in the common or popular breeds. I have to say that network is not the right term since I know of no network in the dog world. However, the more popular a breed is it stands to reason there are more people involved with that breed and that might mean it is easier to find help. However, in reality, within the performance area of dog games most every one I know would not base their assistance on what breed you have. If you are playing their game most everyone would help in any way they can.
Re: what breed has the best network in your opinion?
ezzy333 wrote:There is not a nickels worth of difference in the common or popular breeds. I have to say that network is not the right term since I know of no network in the dog world. However, the more popular a breed is it stands to reason there are more people involved with that breed and that might mean it is easier to find help. However, in reality, within the performance area of dog games most every one I know would not base their assistance on what breed you have. If you are playing their game most everyone would help in any way they can.
Well I wouldn't know what other term besides "network" would describe the group of breeders and trainers responsible for the advancement of a breed......
Community might be applicable I suppose.
- CDN_Cocker
- Rank: 5X Champion
- Posts: 1417
- Joined: Wed Mar 06, 2013 5:59 pm
- Location: ON, Canada
Re: what breed has the best network in your opinion?
I think retrievers have a huge network. There are retriever clubs everywhere. If i was picking a dog on that I would go with a lab.
Re: what breed has the best network in your opinion?
I'd have to say there are a lot more Coon and Beagle clubs around then bird dog clubs.
- Brazosvalleyvizslas
- Rank: 5X Champion
- Posts: 1340
- Joined: Sat Sep 29, 2012 9:20 am
- Location: Soon2be, Texas
Re: what breed has the best network in your opinion?
Labs by far followed by GSP's and Britts. It really depends on the area and local clubs though.
Re: what breed has the best network in your opinion?
Network- a noun meaning a connection. Lots of clubs that promote a certain breed, lots of trainers that are seldom breed restricted, lots of trials that have some restricted and some not, and lots of shows that are seldom breed restricted. And as far as I know most are not networking but will work with anyone and their dog.
Re: what breed has the best network in your opinion?
What realms would that be?luvthemud wrote:
And neither would I, however in other realms, this type of thing can be the deciding factor to choose one over another.
I think you are looking for a support structure, and has been explained, it depends more on the application and activity than breed. I have campaigned Brittanys against pointers/setters, goldens with Labs, and Boykins with springers with success and acceptance, often the only one with my breed.
Re: what breed has the best network in your opinion?
Powersports come to mind off the top of my head. Lots of people choose ATVs based on the network/support structure/community surrounding a particular brand or unit.Neil wrote:What realms would that be?luvthemud wrote:
And neither would I, however in other realms, this type of thing can be the deciding factor to choose one over another.
I think you are looking for a support structure, and has been explained, it depends more on the application and activity than breed. I have campaigned Brittanys against pointers/setters, goldens with Labs, and Boykins with springers with success and acceptance, often the only one with my breed.
Re: what breed has the best network in your opinion?
Sort of what I concluded after browsing the events forum and google. Wasn't sure about labs, but figured since they are so popular that they must have a pretty good setup.Brazosvalleyvizslas wrote:Labs by far followed by GSP's and Britts. It really depends on the area and local clubs though.
Re: what breed has the best network in your opinion?
I also might add that the pointing breeds have multiple venues, like NAVHDA, GSPCA, etc. Something for every one. What will you be doing with the dog? Competition? Pure hunting? Lap dog watching TV with you? This may get you on the right track.
A network is a group of like minded folk sharing ideas, and experiences. I grok that completely.
A network is a group of like minded folk sharing ideas, and experiences. I grok that completely.
-
- GDF Junkie
- Posts: 1630
- Joined: Tue Feb 16, 2010 7:23 pm
- Location: State?...The one where ruffed grouse were.
Re: what breed has the best network in your opinion?
luvthemud wrote:
Powersports come to mind off the top of my head. Lots of people choose ATVs based on the network/support structure/community surrounding a particular brand or unit.
Dogs and ATVs..interesting comparison re purchasing decisions.
I can't quite see looking into an ATV's eyes.
Just me but I would avoid any "network"...often, far too full of people.
Re: what breed has the best network in your opinion?
I am not considering a dog. I simply asked because it seems like the same breeds mentioned over and over in the events section. Was curious I this was indicative of simply popularity, or if these breeds representatives simply got it going on.markj wrote:I also might add that the pointing breeds have multiple venues, like NAVHDA, GSPCA, etc. Something for every one. What will you be doing with the dog? Competition? Pure hunting? Lap dog watching TV with you? This may get you on the right track.
A network is a group of like minded folk sharing ideas, and experiences. I grok that completely.
Re: what breed has the best network in your opinion?
Mountaineer wrote:luvthemud wrote:
Powersports come to mind off the top of my head. Lots of people choose ATVs based on the network/support structure/community surrounding a particular brand or unit.
Dogs and ATVs..interesting comparison re purchasing decisions.
I can't quite see looking into an ATV's eyes.
Just me but I would avoid any "network"...often, far too full of people.
There are people who purchase things of all types based on all types of reasons.
Your last statement is sort of the flip side of the coin. Bigger isn't always better, and I see many owners of lesser common breeds actually consider the tighter/smaller community a positive.
Re: what breed has the best network in your opinion?
If your question has not been answered, then I still don't understand it.
I have bought 8 or 9 atv's and did not consider a community. I did make sure service and warranty work was available, neither applicable to dogs.
If you are not interesting in assistance in getting a dog, I can't help you.
I have bought 8 or 9 atv's and did not consider a community. I did make sure service and warranty work was available, neither applicable to dogs.
If you are not interesting in assistance in getting a dog, I can't help you.
Re: what breed has the best network in your opinion?
Neil wrote:If your question has not been answered, then I still don't understand it.
I have bought 8 or 9 atv's and did not consider a community. I did make sure service and warranty work was available, neither applicable to dogs.
If you are not interesting in assistance in getting a dog, I can't help you.
You are correct. Your postings are of no help. Others seem to understand quite perfectly, and have given their opinions and answered the question. Thank you.
-
- GDF Junkie
- Posts: 1630
- Joined: Tue Feb 16, 2010 7:23 pm
- Location: State?...The one where ruffed grouse were.
Re: what breed has the best network in your opinion?
Yes....but, I have yet to equate a dog with a thing.luvthemud wrote:There are people who purchase things of all types based on all types of reasons.
The Old Hemlock Family, perhaps.luvthemud wrote:Your last statement is sort of the flip side of the coin. Bigger isn't always better, and I see many owners of lesser common breeds actually consider the tighter/smaller community a positive.
Re: what breed has the best network in your opinion?
Well you certainly communicated your opinion of me clearly.luvthemud wrote:Neil wrote:If your question has not been answered, then I still don't understand it.
I have bought 8 or 9 atv's and did not consider a community. I did make sure service and warranty work was available, neither applicable to dogs.
If you are not interesting in assistance in getting a dog, I can't help you.
You are correct. Your postings are of no help. Others seem to understand quite perfectly, and have given their opinions and answered the question. Thank you.
Re: what breed has the best network in your opinion?
http://www.medicaldaily.com/looking-dog ... ans-329896Mountaineer wrote:luvthemud wrote:
Powersports come to mind off the top of my head. Lots of people choose ATVs based on the network/support structure/community surrounding a particular brand or unit.
Dogs and ATVs..interesting comparison re purchasing decisions.
I can't quite see looking into an ATV's eyes.
Just me but I would avoid any "network"...often, far too full of people.
Re: what breed has the best network in your opinion?
So that's what you mean by which dogs have the best network - like, you know, CBS with the big eye logo coming up on screen?luvthemud wrote:http://www.medicaldaily.com/looking-dog ... ans-329896
I'm with Neil - don't quite fathom where you're coming from. If you're alluding to which have the best breed clubs, there are plenty to choose from: Goldens, Brittanies, Chesapeakes, Labs, Flatcoat retrievers - not necessarily in that order.
If you're meaning which dogs give the best emotional bang for the buck while looking you in eye (i.e., "networking"), that would be down to personal choice and oxytocin levels. http://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/04/1 ... eyes/?_r=0
MG
Re: what breed has the best network in your opinion?
If you are talking about pointing dogs, I would attend a NSTRA trial. These trials have dogs of every breed represented. NSTRA is a walking trial with scoring on the dog for pointing, field coverage, obedience and retrieve. I use it for off season recreation. Our club is very family orientated. You will find trainers running various breeds as well as owner handlers. There are 3 trials scheduled in Wisconsin , this and next month. You are always welcome to come out, watch and ask questions. Go to NSTRA.com . look up Wisconsin or Michigan region and search upcoming trials.
Re: what breed has the best network in your opinion?
now you guys are getting it! Spent the weekend running coaxial and installing the dish on the dog house. Trying to decide between netflix or hulu at the moment......crackerd wrote: So that's what you mean by which dogs have the best network - like, you know, CBS with the big eye logo coming up on screen?
MG
-
- Rank: Junior Hunter
- Posts: 42
- Joined: Wed Jan 31, 2007 12:32 pm
- Location: McAdam, NB Canada
Re: what breed has the best network in your opinion?
If you consider American Field a "network" it would be a pretty big one. Magazine printed once a week with trial reports and advertisements for every AF trial in the country.
-
- Rank: Champion
- Posts: 301
- Joined: Thu Jan 01, 2015 11:39 pm
Re: what breed has the best network in your opinion?
Internationally. They print what happens up here in Canada as well.x Bred Pointer wrote:If you consider American Field a "network" it would be a pretty big one. Magazine printed once a week with trial reports and advertisements for every AF trial in the country.
- chiendog
- Rank: Master Hunter
- Posts: 222
- Joined: Tue Apr 20, 2004 8:34 pm
- Location: Great White North
Re: what breed has the best network in your opinion?
This is an excellent question actually. And the answer, in my view, is: 'it depends on where you live'. All breeds, even the most popular and widespread, tend to be found in 'clusters' of populations in various areas. For example, GSPs are very popular throughout the world and there are a ton of them around..but they are not evenly spread out. If you plotted them all on a map you would see clusters of excellent breeders and dogs, trainers, handlers, clubs etc. in some areas of the country (or state) while in other areas you'd have nothing going on for that breed.luvthemud wrote:Just sort of curious....I am always seeing different events being posted and seeing links to breeder organizations, testing sessions, and whatnot. Without starting a back and forth....if a person were to want to buy a dog based solely on the amount of quality resources available for that specific breed, which one would it be? What breed really has a strong "network"?
Of course, with the Internet, distance does not mean the same thing as it used to, so one can get solid support from others in the same breed even if there isn't another dog of the breed within 500 miles. Case in point, my Longhaired Weimaraners from Germany. There are maybe two or three others in the entire county (i live in Canada). But with the Internet, I can have excellent support and networking abilities with a strong and dynamic club and awesome breeders in Germany. Still, it's not the same thing as having a solid group of like-minded folks close by to lend a hand when you need it and to enjoy training, testing and hunting dogs with.
So, you may want to reframe your question by asking "What breed really has a strong "network that is close enough to me and accessible enough to make a big difference?
In my area, the answer would be Labs. They are, by far, the most popular gundog breed around here (pointing dogs of any breed are hardly even on the radar). Labs have a good club, there are good breeders breeding good dogs for hunting and there is a strong, active training, trialling and hunting scene for them. So its a no-brainer. If network and support are the most important factors, the Lab beats all others, hands down in my area.
Re: what breed has the best network in your opinion?
Thank you. Answered my question perfectly. I suspected that labs did have a strong network, but my area is essentially "backyard breeder" types, so I don't get to see it.chiendog wrote:This is an excellent question actually. And the answer, in my view, is: 'it depends on where you live'. All breeds, even the most popular and widespread, tend to be found in 'clusters' of populations in various areas. For example, GSPs are very popular throughout the world and there are a ton of them around..but they are not evenly spread out. If you plotted them all on a map you would see clusters of excellent breeders and dogs, trainers, handlers, clubs etc. in some areas of the country (or state) while in other areas you'd have nothing going on for that breed.luvthemud wrote:Just sort of curious....I am always seeing different events being posted and seeing links to breeder organizations, testing sessions, and whatnot. Without starting a back and forth....if a person were to want to buy a dog based solely on the amount of quality resources available for that specific breed, which one would it be? What breed really has a strong "network"?
Of course, with the Internet, distance does not mean the same thing as it used to, so one can get solid support from others in the same breed even if there isn't another dog of the breed within 500 miles. Case in point, my Longhaired Weimaraners from Germany. There are maybe two or three others in the entire county (i live in Canada). But with the Internet, I can have excellent support and networking abilities with a strong and dynamic club and awesome breeders in Germany. Still, it's not the same thing as having a solid group of like-minded folks close by to lend a hand when you need it and to enjoy training, testing and hunting dogs with.
So, you may want to reframe your question by asking "What breed really has a strong "network that is close enough to me and accessible enough to make a big difference?
In my area, the answer would be Labs. They are, by far, the most popular gundog breed around here (pointing dogs of any breed are hardly even on the radar). Labs have a good club, there are good breeders breeding good dogs for hunting and there is a strong, active training, trialling and hunting scene for them. So its a no-brainer. If network and support are the most important factors, the Lab beats all others, hands down in my area.
- chiendog
- Rank: Master Hunter
- Posts: 222
- Joined: Tue Apr 20, 2004 8:34 pm
- Location: Great White North
Re: what breed has the best network in your opinion?
You are welcome! If your area is sort of 'between clusters' with no dynamic group of breeders in one particular breed, then look for breeds that have a strong national or even international support system and network. If you are looking for a pointing breed, and if you are a 'club' kind of guy, then look at the Drahthaar (GWP). That breed has a very strong club in the US (and Canada) and is the largest, best networked breed in Germany. Just makes sure that the breed is for you and that the structure of the club is for you. If both are a good fit, then you will have a ton of support.
If you are not a club sort of guy and not into following a relatively narrow road when it comes to breeding, testing etc. look at English Setters and Pointers. Chances are there are some darn good breeders not too far from you and since those breeds have a ton of history in America with a big, strong, dynamic field trial and breeding scene, you should be able to find a dog in either of those breeds that fits your hunting style and a breeder that can mentor you and get you connected with whatever network he or she is part of.
Another option is to connect with your local NAVHDA chapter and see which breed is top dog. Most chapters tend to have one breed that is most popular...some chapters are almost exclusively one-breed. But it differs from region to region. So check out what is local to you.
Good luck in your search!
If you are not a club sort of guy and not into following a relatively narrow road when it comes to breeding, testing etc. look at English Setters and Pointers. Chances are there are some darn good breeders not too far from you and since those breeds have a ton of history in America with a big, strong, dynamic field trial and breeding scene, you should be able to find a dog in either of those breeds that fits your hunting style and a breeder that can mentor you and get you connected with whatever network he or she is part of.
Another option is to connect with your local NAVHDA chapter and see which breed is top dog. Most chapters tend to have one breed that is most popular...some chapters are almost exclusively one-breed. But it differs from region to region. So check out what is local to you.
Good luck in your search!
Re: what breed has the best network in your opinion?
My dogs prefer Netflix. Hulu Plus has commercials even though you are paying for the service.luvthemud wrote:now you guys are getting it! Spent the weekend running coaxial and installing the dish on the dog house. Trying to decide between netflix or hulu at the moment......crackerd wrote: So that's what you mean by which dogs have the best network - like, you know, CBS with the big eye logo coming up on screen?
MG
Re: what breed has the best network in your opinion?
With your definition of network I think you would find the answer to be whichever dog is most popular in your area, But like said by someone it will be different in different areas, new Orleans area will be different than eastern mid-west as will N. Dakota. And in truth the areas will likely be much smaller than you think, maybe just 10 or 20 miles down the road.
ezzy
ezzy
Re: what breed has the best network in your opinion?
I'd agree with it being regional. Around here, those of us with any kind of pointing/v-dog have to band together because there are not enough folks with one particular breed or another to do anything worthwhile.
However, there are several lab focused training groups close by.
However, there are several lab focused training groups close by.
Re: what breed has the best network in your opinion?
This is why I question the idea of networks by breeds. Many of us own our favorite but we "network" with people with dogs, people with hunting dogs, people with pointing hunting dogs and finally with the only breed worth it's salt, people with Britts or some other inferior breed. lol41magsnub wrote:I'd agree with it being regional. Around here, those of us with any kind of pointing/v-dog have to band together because there are not enough folks with one particular breed or another to do anything worthwhile.
However, there are several lab focused training groups close by.